|
OER Project Community
  • User
  • All Groups
    • Big History
    • World History
    • World History AP ®
    • Climate
  • Teacher's Lounge
    Announcements, tips & more
  • More
  • Cancel
  • Replies 24 replies
  • Subscribers 12 subscribers
  • Views 8842 views
  • Users 0 members are here
  • unit 1
  • BHP
  • Origin Stories
Related

Origin Stories

Jason Manning
Jason Manning over 3 years ago

One of my goals this year is to take lesson plans that I have done for awhile and give them a second look.  Is there a better way to teach this?  Is the question I am gong to ask myself especially with lessons that I have repeated over several years.  The first lesson I want to look at is Origin Stories.  After reflecting on what I do, I feel like my students walk away understanding one origin story really well and then the others fall short.  In my lesson I ask each row to become a "mini expert," in one story then I create new groups and jigsaw the stories.  My data shows they understand the one origin story they started with but lack any understanding of the other stories that were jigsaw in the group.  Has anyone out there tried a better way to teach this important foundation concept of Big History?  

  • Reply
  • Cancel
  • Cancel
Parents
  • Laura Massa
    Laura Massa over 3 years ago

    Hi Jason Manning I do basically the same as Kimberly Milligan does with her students. I let them choose an origin story, though I try to diversify the narratives and give them those that are unknown to them (Chinese, Iroquois, Mayan, Zulu, and Efik) because Judeo-Christian and Greek are or were covered in other courses. I give them ample variety of modalities as Kimberly mentioned. The one thing I request is that they bring a 3-D representation model of their origin story. It doesn't have to be time consuming. I encourage them to utilize materials available at home, apply their creativity, and bring props to better illustrate their story, something meaningful. Some students create dioramas, others bring a figure that symbolizes the creator of their origin story, and others who are experts in animation, create a story using an ad hoc software. I also ask them to guide their presentations with these ideas in mind:

    • What is the source of the world? or What happened before creation?
    • What or who created the world?
    • How was the Earth created or formed?
    • When was the Earth created?
    • What life forms were created?
    • How were humans formed or created?
    • What was the relationship between humans and animals/plants? Were they powerful, independent, subservient? 
    • Is there any moral in your story?
    • How do people live or behave today according to this origin story? Explore if they perform rituals, build architecture, dance, etc. 

    At the end of the presentations, which take no longer than 5 minutes each, we debrief and reflect upon them, realizing that there is neither logic nor scientific evidence. Then we compare their stories with the scientific origin story of Big History. My goal is that students realize that all origin stories try to make sense of a world prior to the scientific and chronometric revolution.

    • Cancel
    • Up +2 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
Reply
  • Laura Massa
    Laura Massa over 3 years ago

    Hi Jason Manning I do basically the same as Kimberly Milligan does with her students. I let them choose an origin story, though I try to diversify the narratives and give them those that are unknown to them (Chinese, Iroquois, Mayan, Zulu, and Efik) because Judeo-Christian and Greek are or were covered in other courses. I give them ample variety of modalities as Kimberly mentioned. The one thing I request is that they bring a 3-D representation model of their origin story. It doesn't have to be time consuming. I encourage them to utilize materials available at home, apply their creativity, and bring props to better illustrate their story, something meaningful. Some students create dioramas, others bring a figure that symbolizes the creator of their origin story, and others who are experts in animation, create a story using an ad hoc software. I also ask them to guide their presentations with these ideas in mind:

    • What is the source of the world? or What happened before creation?
    • What or who created the world?
    • How was the Earth created or formed?
    • When was the Earth created?
    • What life forms were created?
    • How were humans formed or created?
    • What was the relationship between humans and animals/plants? Were they powerful, independent, subservient? 
    • Is there any moral in your story?
    • How do people live or behave today according to this origin story? Explore if they perform rituals, build architecture, dance, etc. 

    At the end of the presentations, which take no longer than 5 minutes each, we debrief and reflect upon them, realizing that there is neither logic nor scientific evidence. Then we compare their stories with the scientific origin story of Big History. My goal is that students realize that all origin stories try to make sense of a world prior to the scientific and chronometric revolution.

    • Cancel
    • Up +2 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
Children
  • Jason Manning
    Jason Manning over 3 years ago in reply to Laura Massa

    Hello Laura Massa  I love your last question here about performing rituals and building architecture.  It is certainly something that I can come to as my class begins the story of human history.  

    • Cancel
    • Up +2 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel