|
OER Project Community
  • User
  • All Groups
    • Big History
    • World History
    • World History AP ®
    • Climate
  • Teacher's Lounge
    Announcements, tips & more
  • More
  • Cancel
  • Replies 7 replies
  • Subscribers 10 subscribers
  • Views 2526 views
  • Users 0 members are here
  • causation
Related

Causation in Puzzle Form

Julianne Horowitz
Julianne Horowitz over 3 years ago

Two posts from last month have been resurfacing in my head quite a bit lately (this community will do that to you!):

  • First, this post from Janet Mann that I sort of misread but it got the wheels turning about using the "puzzle" concept in class.
  • Second, this post from Carla Geovanis  about using in-class readings in fun ways.

Based on those conversations, I tried to raise the joy-factor when assigning a short article on the causes of the Global Great Depression.  I did it with my AP US History students, since I had already passed this lesson with my world history students, but really it was a test-run so that I can use it next January in WHP.

While students were doing the reading, I randomly dropped one puzzle piece on each kid's desk.  The pieces had one of the five causes for the Depression that were named in the article.  I also placed 5 blank red papers around the room.   (25 students:  5 causes each = 5 final "puzzles" assembled on red paper in the end)

Their instructions after reading were to stand up, roam to find people holding the other causes, and then fit their puzzles together according to what they read.

The great thing about it was that it was a quick and informal check-for-understanding, it got kids moving, and they all came out a little differently which prompted an organic discussion about how these 5 factors contributed to a Great Depression.

Win-win.

I'll definitely be trying this with the tenth graders next year.

 Jason Manning , I know you are about to expand on the Alphonse/causation lesson with your ninth graders, do you think this could work well with any particular Big History article?

 Janet Mann , based on your original post, I thought that the blanks were such a smart idea you had!   How would you insert some "blanks" for this activity? Would you omit one cause and ask students to recall it?  Or do you think they might be able to pull together enough outside information to add a fresh one?  

  • Reply
  • Cancel
  • Cancel
  • Carla Geovanis
    Carla Geovanis over 3 years ago

     Julianne Horowitz I love that idea! I think we could do this with the hexagrams, too. I'm curious--where did you get your puzzle piece template? Do all of the pieces potentially fit with each other?

    • Cancel
    • Up +1 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Julianne Horowitz
    Julianne Horowitz over 3 years ago in reply to Carla Geovanis

    Hi Carla!  I used these Slides to make pieces - feel free to adapt.  I liked the fact that they were all interchangeable from every side so that the connection possibilities were maxed.    With WHP I'll adjust the causes to match this article from Bennett Sherry  - it's more student-friendly than my AP reading, and it still leaves open possibilities for puzzle connections. 

    • Cancel
    • Up +1 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • John Vidoli
    John Vidoli over 3 years ago

     Julianne Horowitz , this is a wonderful activity. It looks like students arranged the causes differently. Did you have them discuss their reasonings for putting the causes together as they did?

    • Cancel
    • Up +1 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Carla Geovanis
    Carla Geovanis over 3 years ago in reply to Julianne Horowitz

    Julianne Horowitz Thank you for that slide template! I have a feeling I'll be using it in several contexts, and it's great that all the pieces potentially connect!

    • Cancel
    • Up +1 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Julianne Horowitz
    Julianne Horowitz over 3 years ago in reply to John Vidoli

    Definitely, yes.  They somehow got the impression that there was just one right answer so they were debating it for a bit.  It was AP though, so, I am curious to see how much discussion it generated in my on-level classes by comparison, although I still think it will work well. 

    • Cancel
    • Up +2 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Jason Manning
    Jason Manning over 3 years ago

    Hi Julianne Horowitz  I love this.  You are always taking ideas and coming up with amazing activities, thank you for looping me in.  When we are back from break I will be tackling the Columbian Exchange and I am looking at the reading in section 8.2 on BHP called Consequences of the Columbian Exchange.  The article is an opportunity to dive into effects rather than causes however I think it can work.  What do you think?  

    • Cancel
    • Up +1 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Julianne Horowitz
    Julianne Horowitz over 3 years ago in reply to Jason Manning

     Hello Jason Manning Consequences of the Columbian Exchange is great fodder for a causation activity!  After looking at the article quickly, my first thought is to have a bunch of effect puzzle pieces, but ALSO a few causes floating around (the cause pieces could be a different color to simplify for the 9th graders), and see if your whole class can make connections that make sense.  It would even make sense to have some of the same things written on a cause-piece to be repeated on an effect-piece for use in a different combination.

    So, two possible clusters that might emerge from the class could look like these:

     

    Causes = Yellow; Effects = White

    This shows how "decline in native population" was used as an effect in the first cluster, but as a cause in the second cluster.

    Let us know how you decide to play around with the article Slight smile

    • Cancel
    • Up +1 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel