|
OER Project Community
  • User
  • All Groups
    • Big History
    • World History
    • World History AP ®
    • Climate
  • Teacher's Lounge
    Announcements, tips & more
  • More
  • Cancel
  • Replies 6 replies
  • Subscribers 8 subscribers
  • Views 1939 views
  • Users 0 members are here
Related

Analysis in Student Writing

Anne Koschmider
Anne Koschmider over 1 year ago

We just did our first structured writing task (not counting DBQ 0) using Claim Testing - The Islamic World. Students seemed to follow along pretty well with their ability to pull evidence to support the statements on their claim cards. However, when it was time to craft a 1-2 paragraph mini-essay based on the groundwork we laid together, I noticed that several students had trouble integrating analysis and reasoning into their writing. 

I’m wondering, how do you coach students to elevate their writing with more sophisticated reasoning?

  • Reply
  • Cancel
  • Cancel
  • Marcella Sykucki
    Marcella Sykucki over 1 year ago

    Thanks for starting this Anne Koschmider and I definitely understand the struggle. Do you have them use a specific structure like ACE in the body paragraphs? When I have them do that it makes it a bit easier. I've also tried giving them sentence starters like "This is important because" or "This relates to the claim that .... because". Adding in Laura Massa to weigh in

    • Cancel
    • Up 0 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Anne Koschmider
    Anne Koschmider over 1 year ago in reply to Marcella Sykucki

    Great point, Marcella Sykucki . I use the ACE strategy for my AP World students when they are writing SAQs but haven't tried it with my on-level students. Thanks for the suggestion!

    • Cancel
    • Up 0 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Katie Raby
    Katie Raby over 1 year ago in reply to Marcella Sykucki

    I also utilize the ACE method. When teaching longer essays, such as the LEQ, I tell them we need to ACEEE. This reminds them that the analysis should be longer in an essay than it would be in a typical SAQ.

    • Cancel
    • Up 0 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Marcella Sykucki
    Marcella Sykucki over 1 year ago in reply to Katie Raby

    I do something similar Katie Raby . What is each E of the ACEEE? I've done it more as ACE1E2CE1E2CE1E2 throughout for my essays. E1 is analyzing the evidence they provided and then E2 is tying that analysis back to the thesis.

    • Cancel
    • Up 0 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Katie Raby
    Katie Raby over 1 year ago in reply to Marcella Sykucki

    E1: This means/shows...

    E2: This is important because...

    E3: This supports the idea that (claim) ...

    I have them repeat it for each claim in the body paragraph. they can mix up the order, but those ideas should be there.

    • Cancel
    • Up +1 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Marcella Sykucki
    Marcella Sykucki over 1 year ago in reply to Katie Raby

    Got it thanks! I usually combine your E1 and E2 as my E1.

    • Cancel
    • Up 0 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel