|
OER Project Community
  • User
  • All Groups
    • Big History
    • World History
    • World History AP ®
    • Climate
  • Teacher's Lounge
    Announcements, tips & more
  • More
  • Cancel
  • Replies 6 replies
  • Subscribers 4 subscribers
  • Views 1930 views
  • Users 0 members are here
  • draw your history
  • whp1750
Related

Draw Your History Student Work

Todd Nussen
Todd Nussen over 3 years ago

One of my goals this year in the community was to share student work that I thought might be helpful to other teachers.  We could reflect together, share our experiences, and think about ways on how to improve or modify our instruction.  That being said, part of that goal was to share examples of impressive work and some that weren't that good.  I have over 50 WHP students this year (10th graders) and another 60 BHP students (9th graders) - some students are going to impress me and some will need some more encouragement next time.  

These are some examples from Draw Your History, which I did during the first week of school in September.  I think this is an important activity to do with students.  It allows them to think creatively and it helps me learn more about my students (even the "bad" ones were revealing).  I love observing the interesting models students come up with: timelines, paths to today, web designs, artistic depictions, etc.  Some share about their family history, culture, religion, while others include important events and as you'll see, some odd or even funny events ("January 2014 -my grandma gets a new dog").  I'm able to learn about serious things that my students might be dealing with like deaths in the family, health issues, friendship problems, questions about sexuality, etc.  Sometimes I forget how tough it is to be a teenager.  When students are willing to share, this activity typically develops into some interesting conversations.  

I'm curious about other experiences with this activity.  Do your students produce similar pieces? Do you modify the activity? Are the weaker submissions still helpful as a teacher getting to know your students during the first few days of school? 

  • Reply
  • Cancel
  • Cancel
Parents
  • Adam Esrig
    Adam Esrig over 2 years ago

    Great student work and excellent questions. I did this activity today and students produced very similar work. As for the as the "drawn histories," I was quite content because this activity works as a wonderful introduction to the course and as an icebreaker.

    Here's where I think I could have done better... I tried my best to engage my students in a question about scale and many did understand the simple idea of... "OK things that have happened before I even existed continue to be part of my story and life." And what a great point to start the school year with...

    ... But then I did see some students really struggle with the Exit Ticket. I culminated the lesson with the question - If your story started 100, one thousand or even 1 million years ago, how would it be different from the one you drew?

    A lot of students understood this to mean "If you were born 100, one thousand or even 1 million years ago, how would it be different from the one you drew?" I know this because they wrote things like "life would be hard and women would have no rights," just as an example. It was a smidge frustrating so I even included a note on my slide to try to clarify (see photo attached). But a lot of students still struggled with opening up the temporal scales of their lives. 

    I'm curious Todd Nussen and others - if you had a similarly worded question or way of wrapping this lesson up that you felt really drove the point home and/or clarified the concept of scale? 

    • Cancel
    • Up +2 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
Reply
  • Adam Esrig
    Adam Esrig over 2 years ago

    Great student work and excellent questions. I did this activity today and students produced very similar work. As for the as the "drawn histories," I was quite content because this activity works as a wonderful introduction to the course and as an icebreaker.

    Here's where I think I could have done better... I tried my best to engage my students in a question about scale and many did understand the simple idea of... "OK things that have happened before I even existed continue to be part of my story and life." And what a great point to start the school year with...

    ... But then I did see some students really struggle with the Exit Ticket. I culminated the lesson with the question - If your story started 100, one thousand or even 1 million years ago, how would it be different from the one you drew?

    A lot of students understood this to mean "If you were born 100, one thousand or even 1 million years ago, how would it be different from the one you drew?" I know this because they wrote things like "life would be hard and women would have no rights," just as an example. It was a smidge frustrating so I even included a note on my slide to try to clarify (see photo attached). But a lot of students still struggled with opening up the temporal scales of their lives. 

    I'm curious Todd Nussen and others - if you had a similarly worded question or way of wrapping this lesson up that you felt really drove the point home and/or clarified the concept of scale? 

    • Cancel
    • Up +2 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
Children
  • Todd Nussen
    Todd Nussen over 2 years ago in reply to Adam Esrig

    I like what you came up with here (definitely gets them to think big). I use the following questions at the end (I think a bunch of them are from the document on the website). 

    Reflection Questions 
    1.  What is the most distant place you mentioned? 
    2.  What is the first event you chose?  Why didn't you choose events from 100 years ago?  1,000 years ago? 
    3.  Why did you pick the facts and events that you picked? 
    4.  How similar/different were your events compared with others in the class? 
    5.  Is it ever possible for a "history of you" to be complete?  What would it mean for a history to be complete? 

    Connections to History 
    6.  Even though you probably chose events from no longer than 15 years ago, how are events from 100 and 1,000 years ago connected to your personal history? 
    7.  Based on your experience creating a history of you, how do you think historians and history teachers choose events to study and teach? 
    8.  Even though we live here and now, why do we study events from different time periods and different places?

    • Cancel
    • Up +3 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel