|
OER Project Community
  • User
  • All Groups
    • Big History
    • World History
    • World History AP ®
    • Climate
  • Teacher's Lounge
    Announcements, tips & more
  • More
  • Cancel
  • Replies 5 replies
  • Subscribers 5 subscribers
  • Views 769 views
  • Users 0 members are here
Related

Are social hierarchies inevitable?

Jim Jaeger
Jim Jaeger 8 months ago

Despite my efforts to avoid social interaction around my neighborhood, the local HOA president cornered me and placed me on the board. This got me thinking about social hierarchy and I posed the question above to my students. We watched the farming and state video from the World History Project and then I asked my students to consider the groups they belonged to (sports teams, work, school, families, etc.). Why was there a need for "someone" to be in charge?

Eventually they came to the point that the larger the group, the more need there was for defining relationships amongst people, determining who had access to resources, to administer justice, and to keep everyone organized. Students mentioned coaches taking time-outs during stressful points of a game and the need for a clear voice. Another mentioned their boss making sure that someone was "on" every job that needed to be completed. One student even mentioned this would be the likely opportunity cost of moving from foraging to farming.  

My next step is to try and turn this into an activity instead of a guided discussion. Anyone try anything like this in your classroom?

  • Reply
  • Cancel
  • Cancel
Parents
  • Drew Fortune
    Drew Fortune 8 months ago

    We had minimesters at my school about 10 years ago. A time between semesters and have school wide programs for about 3 days. I tried to play Survivor in class. I figured: Let’s make them struggle for power. Why? No idea, but the school gave us little resources or framework and we had to have something. 

    I set up challenges. Trivia, puzzles, physical tasks that wouldn’t get me fired (Throwing frisbee the furthest, tug of war, etc). I hid immunity idols. I imagined students forming alliances, negotiating, thinking critically about leadership and game theory. Instead, they went feral.

    Alliances formed in seconds. A kid found an idol and immediately lied about it, for the drama. Challenges turned into chaos. One kid refused to participate. Another played way too hard. Then the voting started. Instead of strategy, they mobbed one kid, not because he was a threat, but because he ate the last bit of candy from a challenge before.

    Within an hour, the game collapsed. I scrapped eliminations. Turned it into a team game. Didn’t matter. They wanted blood. By the end of the day, we had learned nothing about leadership, but a lot about revenge, and the next day I just had us walk the Nature Trail and read Walden out loud as we found nice trees.

    I never did anything like this again in my career, so I am curious if anyone else has a much better idea than I did, which isn't saying much because this idea was one of my worst.

    • Cancel
    • Up 0 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
Reply
  • Drew Fortune
    Drew Fortune 8 months ago

    We had minimesters at my school about 10 years ago. A time between semesters and have school wide programs for about 3 days. I tried to play Survivor in class. I figured: Let’s make them struggle for power. Why? No idea, but the school gave us little resources or framework and we had to have something. 

    I set up challenges. Trivia, puzzles, physical tasks that wouldn’t get me fired (Throwing frisbee the furthest, tug of war, etc). I hid immunity idols. I imagined students forming alliances, negotiating, thinking critically about leadership and game theory. Instead, they went feral.

    Alliances formed in seconds. A kid found an idol and immediately lied about it, for the drama. Challenges turned into chaos. One kid refused to participate. Another played way too hard. Then the voting started. Instead of strategy, they mobbed one kid, not because he was a threat, but because he ate the last bit of candy from a challenge before.

    Within an hour, the game collapsed. I scrapped eliminations. Turned it into a team game. Didn’t matter. They wanted blood. By the end of the day, we had learned nothing about leadership, but a lot about revenge, and the next day I just had us walk the Nature Trail and read Walden out loud as we found nice trees.

    I never did anything like this again in my career, so I am curious if anyone else has a much better idea than I did, which isn't saying much because this idea was one of my worst.

    • Cancel
    • Up 0 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
Children
  • Jim Jaeger
    Jim Jaeger 8 months ago in reply to Drew Fortune

    Drew Fortune LOL  This is awesome, but sorry for the issues you faced because of it.  Good save at the end with Walden. Slight smile

    • Cancel
    • Up 0 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel
  • Eric Schulz
    Eric Schulz 7 months ago in reply to Jim Jaeger

    Jim-my reaction to Drew was the same.  LOL.  I am also sorry this went off the rails.  

    • Cancel
    • Up +1 Down
    • Reply
    • Cancel